Careful with that word

Tuesday, August 16, 2005 | comments (8)
Last night I went to the National Press Club to see John Irving read from his new book, "Until I Find You." It was really cool seeing John Irving live and in person, but the evening was not without it's oddities.

I've been a fan of Irving's since my early teens. Back then, I was definitely drawn to his knack for weaving strange sexual threads into his plots, which were themselves plenty strange to begin with. A mother killed by a foul ball. A boy conceived by a paralyzed soldier with an indefatigable erection. And, of course, at the heart of it all there always seemed to be a boy who had a close relationship to his mother, a distant or absent father, and who was fated to achieve something great. This was good fuel for my 16-year old brain. This was material I could sink my teeth into. And I did, reading every novel of Irving's up to "A Son of the Circus," which was published in 1994.

I have to admit that when Irving came out to the podium, I felt a momentary feeling of shock followed by an irresistible urge to applaud. I think I even heard some people in the audience gasp when they saw him. It's that knee-jerk reaction you feel when seeing somebody famous up-close whose work has had a profound effect on you. There's a certain amazement that comes over you for a few moments. This was evinced best by the two ridiculous women who introduced him and flittered and fluttered around like schoolgirls at the prom fawning over the quarterback. I felt embarrassed for them and I think their nervous introduction helped ground the rest of the people in the room.

Irving reads eloquently, the way you would imagine his prose should be read. His delivery is quiet and precise, and you can detect a faint New England accent on more than a few syllables. His voice has a slight roughness to it, like a fine-grain sandpaper, perhaps a 500- or 600-grit. You wouldn't use it for heavy projects, like removing layers of paint from wood, but you might use it to smooth a blemish off an antique table. He's not what you expect a writer to look like, either. He's typical wrestler: short with a wide, but solid, frame. At 55, he's still somebody with whom you'd think twice about picking a fight.

Now, while I thoroughly enjoyed the event, there were a couple of things about it that seemed somewhat 'off.' First of all, Irving prefaced and concluded his reading with a surprisingly thorough synopsis of the book. This was entertaining in it's own way; however, he told so much about the story through these bookend remarks that if I had just purchased the 800-page hardback at $25 I might have been slightly pissed off. Irving's preface and epilogue to his reading, complete with thematic explanations and character outlines, could have been sent directly to the publishers of Cliff's Notes or Reader's Digest. I thought it was funny that a writer known for his long-windedness had actually abbreviated his novel into an author's version of the 'elevator pitch.'

Another odd thing: the selection Irving chose to read had an over-abundance of the word 'penis' in it. Most people reading this blog know me and know I'm not a prude, but having John Irving drop the 'p-bomb' at least two-dozen times in the course of the evening became a tad uncomfortable, even for me. This had less to do with the word itself as it did with the delivery of the word, which was read with the same eloquent, proper tone as the rest of the selection, much the way a doctor might read from a medical textbook about some odd discoloration or birthmark on the very same organ. It definitely had a shrinking effect, not unlike a cold shower.

The evening wasn't all strange. My favorite part came after Irving finished his reading and talked some about the writing process itself. Some things he said that I found interesting:
  • He has no choice in his subject matter. It just is.
  • While his characters aren't always autobiographical in so much as they are based on real people, he thinks there is something autobiographical in the fact that he keeps inventing them.
  • He writes all his novels from end to beginning. He must know the end and the beginning before he can begin. He approaches each chapter in the same way: end, beginning, fill in the middle. I thought this was fascinating if for no other reason than it is so different from the way I approach any writing project.
  • It took him 7 years to write his latest book, and a couple of years were just spent outlining ideas and discovering the story before he even put pen to paper.
  • I learned that a 'Rose of Jericho' tattoo was a rose with a vagina hidden somewhere in it.
As I said, I haven't read anything by Irving in a long time. I'm not completely sure why. It's wrong to say I 'outgrew' him. He is a master of language and, simply put, you can't 'outgrow' him. I guess the only thing to say is that my taste has changed. I blame it on the Internet! (I'm only partly kidding.) I think the main thing is that Irving's prose has become a little too polished for me. It makes me feel less like I'm reading an edgy novel by a modern author and more like I'm reading something from a time that is not my own.

Update:

John Irving appeared on the Daily Show today, August 17th. Starting sometime tomorrow, you should be able to see it here for at least the next week or two. After that, it may get relegated to the archives.

Update 12.05.2006

In case you're curious what a Rose of Jericho tattoo looks like, it's probably something like this:

Rose of Jericho Tattoo

A reader forwarded me this great pic. (Thanks F!)

link to this | comments (8) | File: 

« The Jones Demo is Here!
A Jones Demo »




Comments

Sounds like an interesting evening, and thank you for the tattoo reference, I've been looking everywhere for one.
Personally, I don't find Irving's prose very polished at all. I'm less impressed with the way the words are placed than with the story he composes. to me, Irving is hardly the master wordsmith. He's a master at plotting a good story.
But that's just my take on him.

Posted by outburst on Dec 28, 2006 at 2:56:05 PM
I was not at all surprised to hear that John Irving writes his books backwards. A Prayer for Owen Meany could ONLY have been written in this way. I have always loved his books and am half way through Until I Find You and am enjoying it immensely.

I am English by the way and my main hobby is reading although I probably read far too much SF and Fantasy than is good for my health!

Posted by Liz on Jul 05, 2007 at 9:05:36 AM
I've never read you before, but found you by searching for a 'Rose of Jericho', because the funny thing is I'm a tattooist who'd never heard of the thing until a friend of mine read Irving's book and became obsessed with actually seeing one.
"Until I Find You" is the first of Irving's works I've ever read and I zipped through that book like nothing I've ever read before (I'm a pretty slow, deliberate reader). He has such a gift. I'm not sure I've been touched by a book like that before (and a read quite a bit). I envy you for having heard him and thank you for sharing your impressions. I find it curious to see how he works as well, from the standpoint of a would-be writer (maybe one day I'll finish).

That book has become a bond between my friend and I, so I finally decided to just compose a Rose for her, but before doing so decided to look it up one last time and here you are.
Thank you for posting this picture :)

Posted by Eliaz McMillan on Dec 03, 2007 at 1:53:40 AM
Interesting about his method. He has a form of dyslexia and I wonder if the way he sees words has any influence on his method of writing?

I too found u thru a search for a picture of the rose. Great post!

Posted by nicole on Jul 11, 2008 at 3:37:56 PM
I just recently finished "The Cider House Rules" I read "Untill I find You" about a year ago. I found Melony and Emma similar and scary. I don't know if anyone else did.

I was in a Tattoo/Piercing shop today and asked one of the employees if they had heard of a "Rose of Jericho" Tattoo. I mentioned the book. He hadn't. He asked if I'd ever google it (I said no) He said he was going to ask. He said it seems like it could be a popular tattoo. I thought it seems like it could be also.

For the record, I have no tattoos. Only piercings in my ears.

Posted by Karen on Jul 12, 2008 at 8:00:32 PM
Fans should check out The Bishop Strachan School in Toronto where this book is clearly set.

Posted by Willie on Mar 27, 2009 at 9:28:30 AM
funny!

i came here looking for a rose of jericho too, after hitting that page in JI's book.

best to all,

d

Posted by david on Apr 27, 2009 at 1:48:27 AM
I love that we all wound up here from the same book! I love reading books set in Ontario and Irving does such a wonderful job at painting a realistic TO.

Posted by Amanda on May 03, 2009 at 4:10:25 PM
Comments: Rss Icon




Yes 
No

  

Related Posts

In rose_of_jericho . . .

08.07.2006
Sometimes reading through the phrases people use to find your site can be kind of scary. For instance, I had one for . . .


In Reviews . . .

05.08.2009
The reason I was able to get lost in this movie was because it did what Star Wars did so well back in 1977, and still does well today: it told a story. And it brought to life compelling characters. That's what it's all about, really. And it's sad and sort of disappointing that you don't see it so much anymore.

06.24.2008
This is an album you need to listen to naked and sweating in an un-air-conditioned room with a slow-spinning fan overhead. Not that I've done that. Twice.

03.21.2008
And so I responded as any self-respecting person would: by drinking too much and watching a great movie--twice--before passing out on the floor of our basement. Escapism through film and unconsciousness through alcohol are great American pastimes. And Tuesday I was a Patriot.

02.13.2008
Casey Dienel has been in pretty heavy rotation on my iPod for close to a year now. Especially the song "Frankie and Annette," which I frequently put on "Repeat One," a setting also known as "OCD? What OCD?"

09.06.2006
A little over a year ago, my friend Tom signed a book deal with Random House. Well, one year and three months later, the book is finally in stores and I wanted to put in a little plug for it, and for Tom's Web site, which I built.

08.02.2006
It was a very humid evening at Wolf Trap Monday night. The only breeze came from the weak movement of air made when somebody opened their mouth to speak.

02.22.2006
I went to see Ana Marie Cox read at the National Press Club tonight.

10.25.2005
Let me come out with it, then: I'm having an affair.

08.09.2005
A tiger, a hyena, an orangutan, a zebra, and a teenage boy are stranded at sea on a lifeboat. Sounds like the setup to a joke, doesn't it?

06.02.2005
If you've been thinking to yourself, Where might I go to smell teriyaki-scented car fresheners, have rubber, decapitated limbs thrown at me, and have brutally graphic, frequently gory, and often horrific prose read to me? - then I have just the thing for


In Books . . .

05.06.2008
The memes have been flying all over the place lately. And I got hit in the crossfire. Twice. One in each leg. So here we go, six plus seven, plus one. Random/Weird/Quirky.

08.02.2007
This could do for reading what last.fm did for listening.

09.26.2006
On Sunday, my friend Tom was interviewed by Liane Hansen on NPR.

09.06.2006
A little over a year ago, my friend Tom signed a book deal with Random House. Well, one year and three months later, the book is finally in stores and I wanted to put in a little plug for it, and for Tom's Web site, which I built.

09.06.2006
Publishing as we know it will die. Sad, but true. The happy part is that it will be resurrected. Saved. JA Konrath's genie told him how. I think they're good ideas.

08.02.2006
Seth Godin throws out 19 pearls of wisdom for authors.

07.19.2006
Unlike my last post, this one is will be short and sweet.

07.17.2006
As somebody who enjoys reading a good book, but who also spends a vast amount of time online, I'm interested in the debate over whether or not Google (or anybody else) should be allowed to scan all of the world's books and make them searchable online.

06.21.2006

06.14.2006
So Sunday I headed off to the bookstore to snatch me up one of these gems. Of course, I quickly realized, you won't find baby-name books in the 'Reference' section of your local Borders.